How to Show Up in AI Answers (Without Begging the Robots)
People now ask ChatGPT for a plumber. They read Google's AI Overview and never scroll to the blue links. So the question I get most this year is some version of: "How do I get the AI to mention me?"
The industry has invented two acronyms for this, GEO (generative engine optimization) and AEO (answer engine optimization). I'll use them so you recognize them when a vendor does. But I'll be honest with you: most of what works is good SEO, done properly, with a few specific additions. Nobody has a secret prompt that makes a chatbot love your business, and you should be suspicious of anyone selling one.
Here's what I'd actually do.
First, understand where the answers come from
AI tools don't make up local business recommendations out of thin air (well, they're not supposed to). When they're answering a question about current information, they generally search the web, read some pages, and summarize them.
- Google AI Overviews are built from Google's own search index. Google has said there's no special markup or separate trick for them. If your page isn't indexed and eligible to appear in regular Google results, it won't show up in an AI Overview.
- ChatGPT search retrieves pages from the web and cites them. OpenAI runs a crawler called OAI-SearchBot for this, and says sites that allow it can appear in ChatGPT's search answers.
The practical upshot: if search engines can't find and understand you, AI tools built on search can't either. Everything in our five-things checklist still applies here. Do that first.
Check you aren't blocking the AI crawlers by accident
Open your robots.txt file. Some security plugins and hosting setups now block AI crawlers by default, and some site owners blocked them on purpose during the "they're stealing our content" panic of a couple of years ago.
That's a legitimate choice. But know the trade-off. If you block OAI-SearchBot, you're telling ChatGPT's search not to read your site, which makes it hard for it to cite you. Look for lines naming crawlers like OAI-SearchBot, GPTBot, PerplexityBot or ClaudeBot with Disallow: / under them, and decide on purpose rather than by default.
One nuance worth knowing: Google's Google-Extended setting controls whether your content is used to train Google's Gemini models. Google says it does not affect your inclusion in Search, including AI Overviews. So blocking it won't remove you from AI Overviews, and allowing it won't get you in.
Write the answer, not the warm-up
AI tools pull passages that directly answer a question. A page that spends four paragraphs on "Since 1998, we have been committed to excellence" before getting to anything useful gives them nothing to quote.
Try this on your most important service page. Write down the five questions customers ask most often. For a roofer, that might be:
- How much does a roof replacement cost?
- How long does it take?
- Do I need to be home?
- Does insurance cover hail damage?
- How do I know if I need a repair or a full replacement?
Then answer each one on the page, under its own heading, in the first sentence or two. Give real ranges and real conditions where you can ("Most single-family roofs take one to three days, depending on size and weather"). Vague answers like "it depends, call us" are honest but useless, both to people and to the machines summarizing for them.
This happens to be what Google has been asking for all along. Funny how that works.
Make your business facts impossible to misread
When an AI tool describes your business, it's stitching together what it found. If your hours are different on three sites, it may pick the wrong one. Keep these consistent and current everywhere:
- Business name, address, phone number
- Hours, including holiday hours
- What you do and don't offer (if you don't do commercial work, say so)
- Service area
Add structured data to your site too. LocalBusiness or Organization schema (in JSON-LD) labels these facts explicitly. It isn't a magic ranking switch, and Google says it's not required for AI features, but it removes ambiguity, and ambiguity is where wrong answers come from.
Your Google Business Profile matters a lot here as well, since it's one of the main places Google gets local business facts.
Be mentioned by people other than you
This is the slow part, and the part no plugin can fake. AI answers tend to reflect what the wider web says about a business: reviews, local news, industry directories, chamber of commerce listings, a podcast you were on, a supplier's "where to buy" page.
You can't control all of that, but you can feed it:
- Ask happy customers for reviews, and reply to them.
- Get listed in the directories that matter in your industry, with accurate details.
- Say yes to the local interview, the guest article, the panel.
- Publish something genuinely useful that other people would want to link to.
If the only place on the internet that says you're the best is your own homepage, the robots notice. So do humans.
How to check if it's working
There's no AI Search Console that tells you every time a chatbot mentions you. So be practical:
- Ask ChatGPT and Google the questions your customers would ask, in plain language, including your city. Note who gets mentioned and what sources are cited.
- Click the cited sources. Those are the pages the tool trusted. What do they have that yours doesn't?
- Look in Google Search Console and your analytics for traffic from AI tools. ChatGPT often adds a
utm_source=chatgpt.comtag to links it sends, so it can show up in your referral reports. - Ask new customers how they found you. Old-fashioned, and still the most reliable data you'll get.
Results vary by question, by user and by day, so don't panic over a single test. Look for patterns over a few weeks.
Want help figuring out where you stand? Request an audience with the Empress at Premazon.